…
Will ban fat-dicked girls and too-handsome short annoying men before addressing any of its actual problems.
Can’t say I’m shocked, US–very on brand.
So in a foamy video (I watched it, so you don’t have to), Donald Trump promises to end ….‘transgenderism’ if he gets reelected…
Sir, your inner cities are wastelands of people forsaken by the government. The safety of US schools is a tragedy, and healthcare a mess. And maybe you’ve heard, but the planet seems to be melting down? Or something? You’ve got 85642878548855 problems on the docket, and they’ll all be waiting for you even after this legislative tantrum against trans people, you griftoid pinhead.
As for anyone else: I’ve gotten jaded talking about Tran stuff, because I’ve realized that railing against trans people fulfills inside some small-minded individuals a need to control SOMETHING. And that this petulant, bullying, childish need to exert control over others’ autonomy (sometimes, regarding issues as pathetically petty as who has the autonomy to wear a dress in public) exists in a realm leagues away from good faith, reason or often even…basic coherency.. But hey, here’s every dumdum anti-trans argument I’ve ever heard, debunked and mocked to rest, once and for all. Rant mode e n g a g e d. Feel free to equip any of these if you encounter them free-range.
‘I’m not anti-trans, but why are they pushing their agenda on young people? Let kids be kids.’
What I hear when people use this argument: I think being gay and/or trans isn’t a superficial qualifier, but a weird sexual fetish that needs to be kept from children. I think gay/trans kids should not be allowed to know that there are people like them in the world They should grow up clueless and in shame, and they should be forced into unhappy lives, pretending they are straight.
—
I am queer, I am trans; my child has known me since he was a baby. …Do people who say this think he didn’t have a childhood, because he knows this basic information about me?
Straight couples’ kids know that they are a couple. They know that men and women have relationships, and that these are called marriage. If children can know about straight people and their relationships in age-appropriate ways–they can know the same parallel information about trans and queer people, and still ‘be kids.’
‘Blah blah bathrooms male predators blah blah I don’t want to be in a bathroom with men.’
Translation when I hear this argument: I don’t want to face the hard fact that sexual predators are often people allowed close to the family/ in the family. I’d rather keep ringing my hands over a hypothetical Man in a Crooked Wig Bathroom Groper than address issues that could protect actual people. Because to do THAT, I would have to examine the skeletons in my own circle’s closet…
—
I don’t know when and where this mythical idea sprung up that *checks notes* public bathrooms are some hotspot for women and/or children to get assaulted by men. It’s beyond odd. If you’re willing to go as far as to rape a woman or molest children, a sign on a door isn’t going to stop you. This is perhaps the most brain-rottey of all these arguments and yet I hear people use it in earnest regularly. The places I’ve most heard about sexual assault happening (especially when it concerned younger people), has been at home/school, by people their parents trusted them to be alone with. So uh yeah… perhaps we should be looking into that.
And sadly, the bathroom panic is ongoing. If you want to here some trans good news in the recent sea of terribleness, check out this absolutely amazing speech by Arkansas senator Clark Tucker, who just now managed to strike down an Arkansas bathroom bill that would criminalize a trans adult as a sex-offender for using a public restroom with a child present. God knows, there is not a lot of good trans news lately, but the measured and passionate way this man laid it all down was a sight of beauty to me. Bravo, Senator Tucker. And thank you. ❤ It’s fifteen minutes, and so worth it.
‘I don’t think teens/young adults are mature enough to make permanent decisions about their bodies.’ : (
Translation when I hear this argument: I don’t actually know the process for how trans people get hormones/surgeries and how difficult and time-consuming it is, and I don’t know actual trans people. I also have no issue with teenagers being in situations that permanently alter their bodies, so long as I’ve deemed that situation ”normal.” (see sports, see forcing pregnant teenage girls to give birth to babies rather than allowing abortion.)
—
The decision to take hormones/get surgeries, is made by and with parents and informed doctors. It is not a simple, fast, or easy process, but people out here acting like the timeline is like this:
Day One: Whoa, am I maybe a girl?
Day Two: Buys pills from the corner WhoreMoan gumball dispenser for two bucks.
Day Three: Check out my sweet, utterly irreversible triple G mommy milkers! Y E S.
Day Four: I’m not ackshually a girl : ( I have huge titties now?? I have no choice, but to sewerslide. : ((((
actual (realistic time line)
Day One: Maybe I might be a…. no. That’s not… just ignore it.
Day Ninety: This is still bugging me.. Could I be a…. no. I’m probably just gay…
Day Two-Hundred: No, this is definitely still bugging me. Should I tell someone? Hmm. Not sure. What if they don’t take it well? Say I’m just doing it for attention?
Year Two: I think… this might be a thing? Should I go see a professional or tell my parents?
Parents: Yoo, you’re just online too much and got some crazy ideas. (*dives back in the closet*)
Year Three: *finally at the doctor* Doctor, I’m thinking I’m trans and I’m really uncomfortable and this has been going on for a while and could we look into hormone therapy?
Doctor: Idk man, let’s just wait twenty more years, just to make sure you don’t REGRET anything. “))))))
Lots of hyperbole thrown in to be funny, but it’s no hyperbole that going from ”i may to trans’ to ‘getting hormones/surgery’ is a step that takes most people YEARS. These changes are not happening (neither internal nor external) over the course of weeks or months. Girl picks up a hammer once; everyone convinces her she’s a boy and her boobs get chopped off in the next half year, is a ridiculous scare-monger situation that is NOT happening.
Also also also? How much you want to bet so many of these ”teens aren’t mature enough to make decisions about their bodies :(“ mothereff’s would have NO PROBLEM forcing a pregnant sixteen-year-old girl to have a baby (an irreversible effect on her body that forces her to take care of an ENTIRE ASS OTHER HUMAN), and top it with a self-righteous: ‘Sixteen is old enough to know the consequences of your actions. If she didn’t want a baby, she knew well enough to not have sex. :(‘ Nah, a lot of these people give zero fucks for teens making long-term changes to their bodies, and their views on abortion make that abundantly clear. (see also here, sports injuries).
Trans ppl consult with doctors. We know the risk and it’s ours to take.
‘body mutilation : (‘
Translation when I hear this argument: Basically the same as above, with a pinch of, I’m actually okay with ”body/genital mutilation” and even performing it on non-consenting children, so long as *I* deem it normal.
—
I know criticism of circumcision makes people uncomfortable regards antisemitic implications, and I am not here to comment on that tradition one way or the other. I don’t have to, because the vast portion of US circumcisions performed are secular, and many of these people clutching pearls about teen and adult ”genital mutilation” have presumably no qualm about slicing off the tip of an infant’s penis (and/or performing non-consensual surgery on infants deemed to have ambiguous genitalia.) But they have problems with adults making informed changes about their bodies. Hmm…
Trump rages on and on in his video about ”child sexual mutilation” (done on trans people)–this is not a thing. Surgery is not being performed on children. Surgery is rarely even performed on teens who have been living as the target gender for a long, long time. It’s just not being done. One, very expensive. Two, see doctors making you wait forever for everything. This is another fabricated nonsense worry.
‘Transgenderism is a cult. : (‘
Translation when I hear this argument: I myself force my beliefs onto my children, so obviously, trans people must be forcing their beliefs onto people. I do not know any other system than forcing people to do and act as I personally see fit.
—
First? ‘Transgenderism,’ is that like, the President of Antifa?
Being trans is not a belief system. There is nothing to ‘believe’ or not believe in.
My kid has asked me in the past, so will I be trans, because I’m your kid and you’re trans? And I told him, who he is (in that respect) has nothing to do with who I am.
So many people are so used to pushing and bullying their own kids into accepting whatever they’ve deemed fit to project onto them, they can’t even fathom allowing someone to come to a conclusion of their own volition, based on a range of info.
Over the years, I’ve had numerous people come to me and ask about trans issues. I always say the same thing: I can tell you what I’ve done and how I feel, but that only applies to me. You have a different body, different goal, different support network, different way of looking at the world. I’m not out here treating coming out as trans as a silver bullet. I’m not proselytizing, I’m not making a war on gender, and if you are happy being the biggest barbie girl stereotypical cis lady (or whoever), I am happy for you and wish you well.
I tell my kid and anyone else, live the way that feels right to you (so long as it harms nobody). Whatever that is. When you are living at peace with yourself, you can help others. When you are bitter and envious of others being free, it is very difficult to help anyone.
‘Be a transblender if you want to. But when you force me to use your name, you compel my speech. : (‘
Translation: I don’t realize that most superficial social interactions between humans are based on a mutual agreement to be respectful. It’s not fair that I can’t be a playground bully around trans people :<
—
This argument I’ve been seeing more lately and it is the unholy poop baby of freedom of speech brain rot. Like holy shit, I’m sorry this is your first day on Planet Earth? ;-; But yes, we absolutely have many instances in society where we are ”compelled” to speak a certain way and if that triggers you, go live in a cave? Idk???
The Wokes did not bring us compelled speech. It’s called seeing people you interact with as a person, and behaving with a baseline of respect. Allow me to demonstrate..
Normal Interaction:
Guy: Hi, my name is Joseph. Please call me Joe.
Me: Hi, Joe.
‘Compelled speech’:
guy: Hi, my name is Joseph. Please call me Joe.
Me: Okay, but uhh… your legal name is Joseph? Right?
Guy: It is, but I go by Joe.
Me: But I want to call you Joseph, I will call you Joseph, and if you make this weird and try to force me to use ”Joe” instead of your legal name, you are COMPELLING MY SPEECH.
….. like, why would you WANT to call someone a name they don’t want you to call them? What nine-year-old playground pissing contest is that??
‘Well I don’t want to use your name because I don’t believe in your -gender ideology- : (‘
Uhhh okay? I don’t believe in a LOT of stuff others believe in, but I’m still going to call you what you want and act normal in a social situation? Grow up loser, we’re having a superficial interaction, I don’t give a hot screw for what you ‘believe’ nor do you have to believe what I believe? Like, conservatives are so soft skinned, they must OUTLAW people with views they don’t believe in?
Baby, I’ve been interacting with complete idiots harboring microwaved hot diarrhea takes my E N T I R E L I F E, and not once have I thought of running to Daddy Dom Government to make them go away. You weak ass little baguettes!!!!!
The same people who complain that gun control leads to a mammy state, when they see a trans person:
HEY DADDY GOVERNMENT!!! This PERSON is doing a thing I don’t LIKE it’s ICKY make them STOP!!!!!!!!
Somewhere I’m sure someone’s written the essay on fascism being the Ultimate Daddy Complex, so I won’t be riffing on that today. I’ll only say: I know conservatives get their panties in a knot when they are compared to fascists, but the way many of them absolutely run to a big strong authoritarian Daddy Figure to make the ookey person they don’t like disappear stanks of the most shutterstock daddy-complex fascist. I’m sorry it’s true. 😦
‘Instead of letting trans people change their bodies, we should be teaching them to accept themselves as they are, and practice self-love. : (”
Translation: I am condescending and should get to tell you what is best for you to ”love yourself..”
For some people, changing their body IS self-love. For some people, changing NOTHING is this love. And everything in between. That’s the neat thing about freedom! You get to decide what’s right for YOU; what’s right for your OWN body, and if you don’t want to do something to yourself, you don’t do it! How cool!!
I think some people are doing this for attention. : (
Translation: I don’t know that humans are social animals and effectively do EVERYTHING for ”attention.” I said this ’cause it sounded good.
—
Humans do a lot of dumb shit for attention. What is this argument? People get married for attention; people attract or break up with partners for attention. Have children for ”attention.” People have always and will always continue to do things for attention, and sometimes, that urge is genuine and coming from a good place, and sometimes, that urge is false. Let them? If they are genuine, they will continue; if they are false, they will get bored of it and stop.
‘I just don’t want you to do something you regret. : (‘
People can still say this with a straight face while straight marriage hasn’t been banned yet?!? Straight families wrote the endboss playbook on crafting regret that endures for GENERATIONS, so. Go raise the kids you wish you hadn’t made, and leave trans people alone, stinky.
I don’t think I can top that line, so. I will pinch this off. Trans friends in the US, times are very dark right now, but I do firmly believe that change always wins. I’m wishing everyone I know there safety, access to healthcare and access to what you need. Keep fighting the good fight and stay strong. The only way to deal with an unfree world is to become so absolutely free that your very existence is an act of rebellion. -Camus
If you want to read about these issues by an erudite and thoughtful writer, please check out Tucker Lieberman’s post on Medium (this post has been knocking in my head for a while, but his post inspired me to finally write it. Thanks for always being an inspiration <3) You can also see the Trump video in his article (it is lower down, as it has already been taken down from the original posted site, but was cached somewhere on an archive. In his article, Tucker picks apart and debunks the talking points of Trump’s… insanely insane video.) A massively recommended read (and his Medium blog is a great resource to subscribe to for ideas–trans, and beyond. <3).
If you want to support a trans woman doing the daunting and terribly draining work of compiling the most recent American trans news into regular posts, I highly recommend Erin in the Morning. You can subscribe and/or support her important timely work with a donation. (Her newsletter is where I first became aware of the Clark Tucker speech.)
That’s all for this one; peace out, moofs.
[‘short annoying men,’ from @BryanOnion on Twitter. I mean, #notall, but enough to be apt :>)
Like this:
Like Loading...